Christian Research Association – 2 recent releases

Spirit Matters:  How making sense of life affects wellbeing by Peter Kaldor, Philip Hughes & Alan Black, (Mosaic Press; Melbourne, 2010)

Shaping Australia’s Spirituality: A Review of Christian Ministry in the Australian Context by Philip Hughes et al (Mosaic Press; Melbourne, 2010)

These two publications examine social research into spirituality and religion  in Australia.  The first is the write up of a 2002 ‘Wellbeing and Security Survey’ which had a sample size of about 1500 Australians (conducted through Edith Cowan, Deakin & NSLC).  The second is an extended discussion prepared for the CRA 2010 National Roundtable conference on ‘Shaping Australia’s Spirituality’, which includes research from the 2009 Australian Survey of Social Attitudes (conducted through ANU) which had a sample size of about 1700 Australians.  The two surveys are not exactly comparable due to variations in the survey questions, but there is enough evidence to suggest that the results back each other up, and that the patterns of spirituality and religiosity described in 2002 are continuing within Australian culture.  Shaping Australia’s Spirituality also draws on research from several other projects and census data.

To GROSSLY over simplify, here is my nutshell reflection:

  • Just under half of all Australians would be happy to call themselves spiritual, religious or both.  What is meant by those terms however, varies a great deal!  Less than half of this group would walk into a church building.
  • The other half of Australians are happy to say they have no religion, but only around 15% of this group intend this as a definitive statement about God or metaphysical realities.  That is, most people who have no religion do so because they don’t care or don’t know enough about it.

Take a look at this helpful table from Spirit Matters: (hope you can read it!)

There have been three perspectives on Australian religiosity and spirituality in recent years, each with a slightly different interpretation of our culture.  Gary Bouma (my old Sociology lecturer!) thinks that there is a ‘low temperature’ culture of religion which is still influential in the Australian psyche.  David Tacey thinks that there is a kind of spiritual revolution going on where Australians are rejecting religion but not spirituality.  Tom Frame argues that most Australians are predominantly secular.  Shaping Australia’s Spirituality suggests that there is evidence for all three perspectives!

This table is derived from the 2009 survey: (please have a giggle at my scanning skills!)

The CRA mob have some helpful suggestions as to where to dig deeper.

  • There is significant interest in a spirituality which connects with nature and grapples with the ecological crisis and may also have it’s roots in the experience of being Australian.  This extends across various categories in the spiritual and/or religious grouping.  If the church grapple with the earth story in a meaningful way, they may yet have a contribution to make to the Australian story.
  • Gender, ethnicity and age are all significant factors in mapping Australian spirituality/religiosity.  For example, the majority of atheists are men over 60.  The majority of ‘fundamentalist’ religious believers are over 70 and/or from a recent migrant population.  Young people (under 30) express more interest in spiritual things than their older counterparts, but simultaneously emphasize the need to create one’s own synchronistic meaning and also express the greatest amount of indecision as to what they believe.
  • The capitalist market approach to life has well and truly infiltrated the Australian cultural expressions of spirituality and religion.  This gives the church two options:  adapt; or define itself as counter-cultural.  Both approaches will gain some interest from some Australians, but counter-cultural sub-groups will by definition be marginal in society.
  • The broader social changes to community formation affect the way that spiritual/religious communities are formed.  Generally speaking, they fall into being either 1. close knit sub-group communities formed around a non-religious social grouping like ethnicity.   2.  networks of friends/family/acquaintances who are gathered by specific events or connections.

My questions:

  • What are the options for a market spirituality approach that remain authentic to Jesus’ vision for humanity?
  • What are the options for network communities of faith that remain authentic to Jesus’ vision for the church?

One thought on “Christian Research Association – 2 recent releases

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s